Chapter 1 — Darwin & the Glutton Club

"The bird was cooked and eaten before my memory returned. Fortunately the head, neck, legs, wings, many of the larger feathers, and a large part of the skin, had been preserved." — Charles Darwin, Journal of Researches (1845), on the lesser rhea he ate before recognising it

T here is a particular kind of hunger that belongs to the naturalist alone, and it is not quite the same as the appetite that sends the rest of us to dinner. It is the wish to know a creature completely — its plumage and its gait, its call and its bones, and, in a century less squeamish than our own, its flavour. The most famous naturalist who ever lived possessed this hunger in full measure, and long before he unsettled the world's account of where species come from, Charles Darwin was a young man who had already made a modest study of eating the ones nobody else would. This chapter follows that appetite from a Cambridge dining room to the far coasts of South America, and tries throughout to keep an honest line between what the record actually shows and the affectionate legend that has grown up around it.

A Society of Hungry Young Men

Before the Beagle, before the barnacles and the finches and the long patient assembling of a theory, Darwin was an indifferent student at Cambridge, nominally reading for the Church and in practice devoting himself to beetles, shooting, and the company of like-minded friends. He was at Christ's College, and the friendships he formed there — with John Maurice Herbert, with Charles Whitley, with Frederick Watkins and John Cameron — mattered to him for the rest of his life; they were the men he rode with, dined with, and collected with while the Reverend John Stevens Henslow, the botany professor who would eventually recommend him for the voyage, was quietly turning a sporting undergraduate into a naturalist. Among the diversions of those years was a small dining society that Darwin and a handful of these companions kept, dedicated to a proposition of some daring: that they should seek out and eat, as the reminiscences preserved in his Life and Letters record, "birds and beasts which were before unknown to human palate." They called it, with the self-mocking grandeur of clever undergraduates, the Glutton Club.

The impulse to know a creature by every means, the mouth included, ran in Darwin before any club gave it a name. His consuming Cambridge passion was not divinity but beetles, hunted with what he called "the mere passion for collecting," and it produced the most celebrated mouth in the history of entomology. "One day, on tearing off some old bark," he remembered in his autobiography, "I saw two rare beetles, and seized one in each hand; then I saw a third and new kind, which I could not bear to lose, so that I popped the one which I held in my right hand into my mouth. Alas! it ejected some intensely acrid fluid, which burnt my tongue so that I was forced to spit the beetle out, which was lost, as was the third one." He had not meant to taste it — the mouth was merely a third hand — but the image of the future author of the Origin standing in a wood with a live bombardier beetle discharging on his tongue is the whole cast of mind in miniature: a man who met the living world with no sense held in reserve.

The name itself was a small joke at another society's expense. By Herbert's account, a rival set of Cambridge men had taken to styling themselves adventurous eaters while in fact dining on nothing more startling than mutton chops, beans and bacon; the Glutton Club's founders proposed to show them what adventurous eating actually meant. The membership was never large — perhaps seven or eight young men who met weekly and dined in one another's rooms in rotation — and beside the Christ's College circle the later accounts name James Heaviside of Sidney Sussex, Robert Blane of Trinity, and Henry Lowe of Trinity Hall. Their method was to hunt down the odd and the overlooked — creatures that never troubled an ordinary English table — and to cook and judge them with the seriousness of connoisseurs. A hawk went into the pot; so did a bittern, one of the heron-like wading birds of the fens, and in its day the loudest bird in Britain. For a time the experiment prospered, in the way that any club prospers while its members are pleased with their own audacity.

What ended it has been mistold often enough to be worth setting straight. The verdict that finished the Glutton Club was not Darwin's but that of his friend Watkins, who long afterward recalled the club coming "to an untimely end by endeavouring to eat an old brown owl which was indescribable! We tried hawks & bittern & other delicacies." That single adjective — indescribable — is the whole obituary of the enterprise, a word doing a great deal of quiet work, and the society seems not to have survived the meal. It is a small correction, but the sort this volume cares about: the famous "indescribable" belongs to a fellow diner's letter, not to Darwin's own pen, and the difference is exactly the kind of drift by which a fond memory hardens into a misquotation.

Two further honesties belong here, in keeping with this volume's rule. The first is that the club is genuinely documented — it is not a later invention — but that much of its surviving colour comes from brief, fond reminiscence written down decades after the fact rather than from any careful minute-book, and the precise roster of what was eaten, and in what order the society met its end, is thinner in the record than the retellings suggest. The second is that the impulse behind it was not mere bravado. The same young man who ate the bittern would, within a few years, be cataloguing the fauna of a continent, and the Glutton Club is best understood not as a stunt but as the undergraduate first draft of a lifelong habit: the conviction that to encounter an animal fully was to leave no sense, including taste, entirely unconsulted.

The Naturalist at the Ship's Table

That habit sailed with him. When Darwin joined HMS Beagle in 1831 as the captain's gentleman companion and unofficial naturalist, he entered a world in which the line between specimen and supper was drawn far more loosely than a modern reader expects. A surveying ship on a five-year voyage could not carry all it needed; fresh meat meant whatever the country provided, and a naturalist ashore with a gun was, of necessity, also a provisioner. Darwin ate his way around South America partly from curiosity and partly because that was simply how one dined at the edge of the charted world, and he recorded the results with the same even attention he gave to rock strata and beetle wing-cases.

His verdicts have a wonderful matter-of-factness, and the best of them concerns a great cat. Riding with the gauchos across the pampas, Darwin came in after dark to the posta on the Rio Tapalguen and sat down to supper, where, he wrote, "from something which was said, I was suddenly struck with horror at thinking that I was eating one of the favourite dishes of the country, namely, a half formed calf, long before its proper time of birth. It turned out to be Puma; the meat is very white, and remarkably like veal in taste." He could not resist the scholar's footnote to his own dinner: "Dr. Shaw was laughed at for stating that 'the flesh of the lion is in great esteem, having no small affinity with veal, both in colour, taste, and flavour.' Such certainly is the case with the Puma." The gauchos, he added, differed over whether the jaguar was good eating "but are unanimous in saying that cat is excellent." It is a small masterpiece of the naturalist's table: horror, correction, judgement, and a peer-reviewed comparison to an eighteenth-century authority, all over a plate the diner had mistaken for veal.

The rodents of the plains drew his two most quotable verdicts, and they pull in opposite directions in a way worth pausing over. In September 1832, near Bahía Blanca, he noted in his diary that he had shot "an Agouti or Cavy" which "weighs more than 20 pounds & affords the very best meat I ever tasted." That is the sentence usually quoted, and rightly; but it repays honest identification. Darwin used agouti and cavy loosely, as travellers did, and a twenty-pound rodent of the Patagonian scrub is not the small tropical agouti at all but almost certainly the Patagonian mara (Dolichotis patagonum), a long-legged cavy that grazes exactly that country. Against this stands his opinion of the largest rodent of all: the capybara, which he met as the "water-hog" of the rivers and pronounced, with a shrug that survives on the page, "very indifferent" eating. The naturalist who loved the mara above every meat of the voyage found its giant cousin barely worth the trouble — a reminder that his palate was discriminating, not indiscriminate.

Nor did the birds escape assessment. Of the armadillos he was fed on the plains he wrote that they made "a most excellent dish when roasted in its shell," and elsewhere that they tasted and looked like duck; of a fierce carrion-hawk, the caracara, he passed along the sealers' report that its flesh "when cooked, is quite white, and very good eating; but bold must the man be who attempts such a meal." Roasted armadillo, veal-flavoured puma, twenty pounds of superlative cavy, indifferent water-hog, and a carrion-bird for the brave: this is not gluttony but fieldwork, flavour entered in the ledger beside weight and range. That the data happened, now and then, to be delicious was to his mind simply another fact worth writing down.

The Ship's Larder

It is worth remembering how a survey ship actually fed itself, because it explains why a naturalist's curiosity and a crew's survival kept meeting on the same plate. The Beagle carried her food as every long-voyage ship did: casks of salt beef and salt pork, ship's biscuit hard enough to break a tooth, dried peas, flour, rum and lime-juice against the scurvy that still shadowed every ocean passage. This was food that kept, not food that pleased, and after a few weeks at sea it grew monotonous to the point of misery. Fresh meat of any kind was therefore precious out of all proportion to its novelty, and a naturalist who went ashore with a gun came back not only with specimens for the jar but with dinner for the mess.

This is the practical root of the whole chapter. Darwin's tastings were not, for the most part, a connoisseur's indulgences; they were the ordinary business of provisioning a ship at the edge of the map, where the difference between a good week and a wretched one might be a brace of birds or a young tortoise stowed below. The curious palate and the empty larder pulled in the same direction, and it is no accident that the naturalist's most vivid food-writing comes from exactly those stretches — Patagonia, the Galápagos — where the tinned and salted stores were furthest away and the country itself had to furnish the table.

Among the Gauchos

Darwin's South American table was not really his own; it was the gauchos'. For months at a stretch he rode with these horsemen of the pampas, and he ate what they ate, which was, to his lasting astonishment, almost nothing but meat. He passed days together tasting nothing else, and watched the gauchos live for weeks on beef alone — not even bread — and remain, to all appearances, the healthier for it. Their manner of cooking he admired for its economy: the carne con cuero, meat roasted with the hide still on so that the juices were sealed within. Their manner of hunting he found thrilling — the bolas, three weighted cords whirled overhead and flung to snare the legs of rhea and guanaco at a gallop. It was in this rough company, and by these methods, that most of his celebrated tastings were caught, killed and cooked; the naturalist's dinner was, more often than not, a borrowed one.

The rhea furnished the plains with more than meat. Its eggs, enormous and pale, were gathered by the gauchos in quantity — Darwin recorded nests holding anywhere from twenty to fifty, and, on the authority of the older Spanish naturalist Félix de Azara, sometimes seventy or eighty — and the scattered, never-to-be-hatched eggs the Spaniards called huachos were valued as food, a single one making a meal in itself. Here, before ever the Beagle reached an island, was the pattern of the whole voyage in little: a creature known first through the stomach — its flesh, its eggs, its habits at the nest — and only afterwards, and partly because of that intimate acquaintance, through the cold discipline of science.

The Larder of the Islands

The same even hand followed him to the Galápagos in 1835, where the strangest fauna he ever met doubled, as everywhere, as the strangest larder. The land iguana of James Island struck him first by its sheer numbers — "when we were left at James," he wrote, "we could not for some time find a spot free from their burrows on which to pitch our single tent" — and then, inevitably, by its merits on the plate. Cut open, the lizards proved to be vegetarians, their stomachs packed with foliage; cooked, he reported, "they yield a white meat, which is liked by those whose stomachs soar above all prejudices." The phrase is pure Darwin, half apology and half challenge, and it marks precisely the line this volume walks: the food is honestly described, the squeamish reader honestly acknowledged, and no verdict pronounced on either.

Not everything on the islands went into the pot, and the exception is as revealing as the rule. The marine iguana — the black, salt-sneezing lizard that Darwin called "a hideous-looking creature, of a dirty black colour, stupid and sluggish in its movements," and watched swimming and grazing on seaweed beneath the surf — he studied and dissected with care, but did not eat. Its cousin ashore yielded, as we have seen, a white meat for the unprejudiced; the sea-going kind he left alone. The naturalist's curiosity had its boundaries, drawn less by principle than by appetite, and the line between the specimen one studies and the specimen one swallows was, even for Darwin, never quite fixed.

The tortoises were the larger subject, and here Darwin's appetite and his science met over the same shell. On James Island, camped in the damp uplands where the animals were most numerous, he and his companions "lived entirely upon tortoise-meat," and his tasting notes are more discriminating than the legend allows: "the breastplate roasted (as the Gauchos do carne con cuero), with the flesh on it, is very good; and the young tortoises make excellent soup; but otherwise the meat to my taste is indifferent." Not, then, a wholesale rapture — a specific commendation of the breastplate and the young ones, and a plain verdict on the rest. He noted too the second harvest the animal yielded, that "the flesh of this animal is largely employed, both fresh and salted; and a beautifully clear oil is prepared from the fat," so that a single tortoise furnished roast, soup, salt-meat and lamp-oil at once. And he recorded, without a flicker, the islanders' emergency use of the creature as a canteen: the tortoise's bladder holds a reserve of fluid, and a thirsty man in the lowlands would kill one and drink it, the liquid in the one Darwin saw opened being "quite limpid" with "only a very slightly bitter taste." A beast that could be eaten four ways and drunk from a fifth was, to the sailing age, less an animal than a commissary.

The Bread of the Fuegians

The islands were not the only place where Darwin's plate and his collecting box closed on the same object. Two years earlier, among the drenched southern-beech forests of Tierra del Fuego, he had met a food that belonged wholly to the people of that coast, and in recording it he did something the rest of this chapter's cast rarely managed: he met an indigenous staple as a cuisine rather than a curiosity.

The food was a fungus, bright and globular and wholly strange to a European eye. It grows only on the southern beeches — the Nothofagus trees — provoking the branch to swell into a woody knot from which the fruiting bodies erupt in clusters of orange and pale-yellow globes. Darwin, the exact observer, set down their look precisely: they were, he wrote, "the colour of the yolk of an egg," and ranged in size "from that of a bullet to that of a small apple." To the Yámana and their neighbours the fungus was no marvel but a mainstay — gathered in quantity, eaten raw, faintly sweet and gelatinous — one of the very few vegetable foods a hunting people could rely upon in that cold and forested land, where almost everything else on the plate came from the sea or the chase.

He collected specimens, as he collected everything, and sent them home; and in 1842 the clergyman-mycologist Miles Joseph Berkeley, the foremost British authority on fungi, described the thing as new to science and named it, all but inevitably, Cyttaria darwinii — Darwin's fungus. Here is the rhea's quiet twin: a second organism that Darwin ate, recorded, and unintentionally lent his name to, a species the world knows as his precisely because he had met it, in part, at dinner. The contrast between the two is the lesson. The rhea he ate by mistake and snatched back from the pot; the fungus he ate on purpose, as his hosts did, and honoured in his notebook as their bread and not his novelty. It is the nearest this chapter's tradition comes to the volume's first commitment — that every strange food is somebody's cherished ordinary — and it is no accident that the man who reached it was the one who troubled to watch how the people of the place actually lived.

Field Note — The Lesser Rhea

Of all Darwin's meals, one has earned a permanent place in the history of science, and it is worth telling slowly because it is so often told carelessly. Along the coast of Patagonia, Darwin had been hearing from the gauchos of a second, smaller kind of ostrich — an avestruz petise, distinct from the common greater rhea of the northern plains — and he had spent some effort trying, without success, to obtain one. Then, near Port Desire around the turn of 1834, the Beagle's draughtsman Conrad Martens shot an ostrich for the pot. Darwin, his mind on other things, looked at it, took it for a two-thirds-grown bird of the ordinary sort, and thought no more about it while it was plucked, roasted, and very largely eaten — by Darwin himself among others.

Only partway through the meal did recognition arrive with a jolt: this was no juvenile of the common species but the very smaller rhea he had been chasing. What followed is one of the more comic scrambles in the annals of natural history. As he wrote, "the bird was cooked and eaten before my memory returned. Fortunately the head, neck, legs, wings, many of the larger feathers, and a large part of the skin, had been preserved" — rescued, in other words, from the dinner things and packed off to England. From those salvaged scraps the ornithologist John Gould, on 14 March 1837, described the bird to the Zoological Society of London as a species new to science and honoured its inadvertent diner by naming it Rhea darwinii. Darwin rose at the same meeting to read his own notes on the two rheas and their ranges. Today the lesser rhea is placed as Rhea pennata — the French naturalist Alcide d'Orbigny had in fact named it three years earlier, so Gould's darwinii survives only as a synonym — but the association clings, and the "Darwin's rhea" of the field guides is, quite literally, a bird its namesake had eaten before he knew what it was.

<figure> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="100%" viewBox="0 0 640 600" role="img"><title>Darwin's Rhea — Rhea pennata, the lesser rhea</title> <rect x="11" y="11" width="618" height="578" fill="none" stroke="#43331f" stroke-width="1.3"/> <rect x="18" y="18" width="604" height="564" fill="none" stroke="#43331f" stroke-width="0.6"/> <path d="M30 30h20M30 30v20" fill="none" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M610 30h-20M610 30v20" fill="none" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M30 570h20M30 570v-20" fill="none" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M610 570h-20M610 570v-20" fill="none" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/>

<path d="M50 512 q70 -20 150 -8 q90 -18 190 -6 q80 -16 170 -6 q40 -6 80 -2" fill="none" stroke="#a9906c" stroke-width="0.9"/> <path d="M40 522 H600" fill="none" stroke="#43331f" stroke-width="1.2"/> <path d="M70 522 l-4 -12 M74 522 l3 -14 M120 522 l-3 -11 M470 522 l4 -13 M474 522 l-3 -12 M540 522 l3 -12" fill="none" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.7"/>

<g fill="none" stroke="#43331f"> <path d="M453 168 L468 177 L453 185" stroke-width="1.1"/> <ellipse cx="440" cy="173" rx="16" ry="12" stroke-width="1.2"/> <circle cx="446" cy="170" r="2.4" fill="#43331f" stroke="none"/> <path d="M424 163 C398 210 372 250 345 296" stroke-width="1.2"/> <path d="M452 185 C430 232 392 268 360 300" stroke-width="1.2"/> <path d="M429 200 l-9 5 M420 224 l-9 5 M408 248 l-9 5 M394 270 l-9 5 M378 288 l-9 4" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.7"/> <path d="M360 300 C366 335 366 366 360 400 C320 424 250 426 205 400 C182 355 180 306 200 286 C238 252 305 250 345 296 Z" stroke-width="1.4"/> <path d="M348 306 C300 322 250 350 222 392 M356 316 C312 334 266 362 236 398 M360 330 C320 348 282 372 252 402" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.9"/> <path d="M215 404 C260 420 320 420 352 402" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/> <path d="M240 296 l4 4 l4 -4 M262 292 l4 4 l4 -4 M286 292 l4 4 l4 -4 M310 296 l4 4 l4 -4" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/> <path d="M232 322 l4 4 l4 -4 M258 320 l4 4 l4 -4 M286 320 l4 4 l4 -4 M314 324 l4 4 l4 -4" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/> <path d="M236 350 l4 4 l4 -4 M266 350 l4 4 l4 -4 M298 352 l4 4 l4 -4" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/> <path d="M328 416 L326 452 L332 505 M336 416 L334 452 L340 505" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M336 506 L356 516 M336 506 L346 520 M336 506 L330 520" stroke-width="1.1"/> <path d="M286 414 L276 452 L256 512 M292 414 L282 452 L262 512" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="1.1"/> <path d="M258 512 L276 518 M258 512 L266 522 M258 512 L252 522" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.9"/> <path d="M352 300 l7 6" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/> </g>

<text x="320" y="562" text-anchor="middle" font-family="'Liberation Sans','DejaVu Sans',sans-serif" font-size="13" letter-spacing="4" fill="#43331f">DARWIN'S RHEA</text> <text x="320" y="578" text-anchor="middle" font-family="'Liberation Sans','DejaVu Sans',sans-serif" font-size="8.5" letter-spacing="3" fill="#6f5a40">RHEA PENNATA</text> </svg>

<figcaption><em>Plate 1. The lesser rhea, Rhea pennata, eaten at Port Desire before Darwin recognised it as new to science; described by Gould in 1837 as Rhea darwinii.</em></figcaption> </figure>

How a Dinner Became a Theory

The rhea is remembered as a comedy, and it is one; but it also sits, improbably, near the origin of the most consequential idea in modern biology, and the mechanism deserves to be spelled out rather than merely gestured at. When Gould pronounced the salvaged Patagonian bird a distinct species rather than a variety of the common rhea, he handed Darwin a problem dressed as an honour. The two rheas, Darwin explained to the Society that March, did not simply live in different countries; they met. The greater rhea, Rhea americana, ranged over the plains of La Plata and Northern Patagonia as far south as a little below the Rio Negro, at about latitude 41 degrees, and there — precisely where one form gave out — "the Petise takes its place in Southern Patagonia." Two closely allied birds, filling the same role in the same landscape, replacing one another across a line on the map with a zone of overlap between them: this was not what a world of fixed and separately created species was supposed to look like. If each kind had been made for its place, why two so nearly identical makings, and why should the join fall just there?

The tortoises pressed the same question from another direction, and Darwin came to see it only in hindsight. Mr. Lawson, the English vice-governor of the little Galápagos colony, had told him almost in passing that the tortoises differed from island to island — that he "could with certainty tell from which island any one was brought." Captain Porter had said the same, that the James Island animals were "rounder, blacker, and have a better taste when cooked" than those of Charles and Hood islands with their saddle-fronted shells. At the time Darwin barely attended; he was eating the evidence, and to his lasting regret the young specimens he did carry home were too immature for even the British Museum's Mr. Gray to separate. Only later did the pattern of the tortoises and the mockingbirds and the two rheas resolve into a single disturbing shape — closely related forms, parcelled out by geography, shading into one another — and only later did he grasp that a world of separate creations had no good reason to arrange itself so. The half-finished rhea dinner was thus not merely an anecdote but a specimen in the most literal sense: a preserved fragment that, read correctly a few years on, helped pull the keystone from the doctrine of fixed species. It is the rare theory whose foundation stone was very nearly digested.

Two further threads make the payoff firmer than the rhea alone can bear. The first is the mockingbirds. Handling his Galápagos skins on the voyage home, Darwin noticed that the mocking-thrushes, like the tortoises, seemed to differ island by island, and in the private ornithological notes he kept in 1836 he let himself write the sentence that changed everything: "If there is the slightest foundation for these remarks the zoology of Archipelagoes will be well worth examining; for such facts would undermine the stability of Species." It is the first faint sound of the whole edifice beginning to move, and it was struck by island creatures he had, in the tortoises' case, been busily eating. The second thread is a point of method. When Gould raised the salvaged Patagonian bird to a species, Darwin's rescued fragments — the head, the neck, the legs, the skin lifted from the dinner things — became its type specimen: the single physical individual to which the name is forever anchored, the standard against which every later rhea is measured. The name Rhea darwinii is thus tied, in the most literal and permanent way the science allows, to the very bird that was carved and eaten at Port Desire. Few species carry their origin so intimately.

The Tortoise, and a Debt Deferred

If the rhea is the chapter's comedy, the Galápagos tortoise is its conscience, and it points ahead to a reckoning this volume will not shirk. The giant tortoises were the archipelago's most famous resource, and for the plainest of reasons: they were enormous — Darwin met individuals that "must have weighed at least two hundred pounds," and heard from Lawson of beasts so large "that it required six or eight men to lift them from the ground" and that yielded as much as two hundred pounds of meat apiece — they were abundant, and they could be stacked alive in a ship's hold for the better part of a year, furnishing fresh meat long after the salt provisions had grown vile. The scale of the harvest was already staggering when Darwin arrived. On Charles Island the population had been so reduced that two days' hunting a week fed the settlers; yet within living memory, Darwin was told, "single vessels have taken away as many as seven hundred, and the ship's company of a frigate some years since brought down in one day two hundred tortoises to the beach." The Beagle itself was no exception, taking some four dozen aboard as walking provisions — a pair kept for a time almost as pets on deck before they, too, went into the coppers on the long haul home, their shells pitched over the side without a note of which island each had come from.

For the sailors of the Pacific this was old routine. A "turpin" hunt was a rite of passage; the largest tortoises, some over five hundred pounds, were lashed to poles and carried down to the boats by two or three men a side, and once below decks the animals lived, uncomplaining and unfed, for months on end. A British sea-captain turned whaler had written as early as 1798 that the meat, "in whatever way it was dressed, was considered by all of us as the most delicious food we had ever tasted." Multiply that appetite across the whaling and sealing fleets of a century and the arithmetic turns grim: the best modern reconstructions estimate that something like a quarter of a million tortoises inhabited the islands when Europeans found them, and that perhaps a hundred to two hundred thousand were carried off, until several island races were gone entirely and the rest reduced to remnants.

A word is owed here to a piece of affectionate folklore, in the spirit of this volume's third commitment. One sometimes reads of "Darwin's Christmas tortoise," as though a particular giant had crowned a particular Beagle Christmas dinner. The plain record supports no such ceremony. What is true is quieter and, in its way, more damning: the ship left the Galápagos in October 1835 and was still working its way westward across the Pacific through that December, so the crew were quite literally eating their way through their stock of living tortoises across the season — Christmas included — with no thought that a single one might have been worth more to science, or to its species, than to the pot. The garnished "Christmas tortoise" is embellishment; the undramatic truth is that the eating simply never stopped.

The losses fell hardest on the island races, and Darwin had a front-row seat without quite grasping it. The tortoises of Charles Island — the very ones whose saddle-fronted shells the vice-governor Lawson could tell at a glance — were being hunted out even as the Beagle lay off the coast, and within a few decades that race was gone entirely, the first of several among the archipelago's dozen-odd forms to vanish outright. The very distinctness that had so nearly set Darwin thinking, island by island, was also precisely what made each race so easy to erase one island at a time: to empty a single small island was to end a lineage found nowhere else on earth. The last survivor of one such extinguished line would, more than a century later, become the most famous tortoise alive and the emblem of everything this book's sixth chapter is about — but that is a story for its proper place.

Darwin's dinner sat near the beginning of that curve, not its end, and it would be a poor kind of naturalism that recorded the flavour and passed over the fate. This book will return, in its sixth chapter, to what the curious eater owes a creature that cannot survive his curiosity; for now it is enough to mark the debt, and to let the tortoise stand as the first quiet warning that appetite and conservation were, even at Darwin's table, already on a collision course.

<figure> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="100%" viewBox="0 0 640 470" role="img"><title>The Galápagos Giant Tortoise — Chelonoidis niger</title> <rect x="11" y="11" width="618" height="448" fill="none" stroke="#43331f" stroke-width="1.3"/> <rect x="18" y="18" width="604" height="434" fill="none" stroke="#43331f" stroke-width="0.6"/> <path d="M30 30h20M30 30v20" fill="none" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M610 30h-20M610 30v20" fill="none" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M30 442h20M30 442v-20" fill="none" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M610 442h-20M610 442v-20" fill="none" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/>

<g fill="none" stroke="#a9906c" stroke-width="0.8"> <path d="M70 414 L128 336 L150 350 L186 414"/> <path d="M110 380 l14 6 M120 366 l14 6"/> </g> <g fill="none" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"> <path d="M560 414 L558 360"/> <ellipse cx="558" cy="350" rx="12" ry="17"/> <ellipse cx="543" cy="331" rx="11" ry="15"/> <ellipse cx="575" cy="333" rx="11" ry="15"/> <ellipse cx="560" cy="312" rx="10" ry="14"/> </g> <path d="M40 414 H600" fill="none" stroke="#43331f" stroke-width="1.2"/> <path d="M120 414 q8 -5 16 0 M300 414 q8 -5 16 0 M500 414 q8 -5 16 0" fill="none" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.7"/>

<g fill="none" stroke="#43331f"> <path d="M240 268 C236 150 490 150 486 268" stroke-width="1.4"/> <path d="M240 268 q16 14 32 0 q16 14 32 0 q16 14 32 0 q16 14 32 0 q16 14 32 0 q16 14 32 0 q16 14 32 0 q13 12 24 0" stroke-width="1.2"/> <path d="M262 178 C320 152 410 152 470 198" stroke-width="1"/> <path d="M258 212 C325 188 405 188 468 226" stroke-width="1"/> <path d="M302 160 L306 202 M350 152 L352 196 M398 154 L400 198 M442 170 L450 212" stroke-width="0.9"/> <path d="M282 208 L270 266 M326 192 L320 268 M372 190 L372 268 M418 194 L430 268 M460 216 L474 266" stroke-width="0.9"/> <path d="M308 180 q20 -16 44 -4 M316 182 q13 -10 30 -4 M380 180 q20 -15 42 -2 M388 182 q13 -9 28 -3" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.7"/> <path d="M420 240 q20 8 34 26 M430 226 q22 8 38 28 M408 250 q18 8 30 24 M446 214 q18 8 30 26" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.7"/> <path d="M360 150 l9 4" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M262 268 C230 248 182 220 152 182" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M278 276 C252 256 202 230 168 190" stroke-width="1.3"/> <ellipse cx="151" cy="176" rx="20" ry="15" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M133 180 L118 184 L133 190" stroke-width="1.1"/> <circle cx="150" cy="172" r="2.4" fill="#43331f" stroke="none"/> <path d="M252 258 l-6 7 M236 248 l-6 7 M218 236 l-6 7 M200 224 l-6 7 M184 212 l-6 7" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/> <path d="M312 308 C308 344 308 382 312 408 L332 408 C336 382 336 344 332 310" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.9"/> <path d="M392 310 C388 346 388 384 392 408 L412 408 C416 384 416 346 412 312" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.9"/> <path d="M270 302 C263 342 263 382 268 410 L302 410 C306 382 306 342 300 305" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M266 330 H304 M265 348 H305 M266 366 H304 M267 384 H303" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.7"/> <path d="M270 410 l-4 6 M282 410 l0 8 M296 410 l4 6" stroke-width="1"/> <path d="M424 306 C418 344 418 384 424 410 L458 410 C462 384 462 344 456 308" stroke-width="1.3"/> <path d="M422 332 H460 M421 350 H461 M422 368 H460 M423 386 H459" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.7"/> <path d="M426 410 l-4 6 M440 410 l0 8 M454 410 l4 6" stroke-width="1"/> <path d="M486 282 q16 6 12 22" stroke-width="1.1"/> </g>

<text x="320" y="432" text-anchor="middle" font-family="'Liberation Sans','DejaVu Sans',sans-serif" font-size="13" letter-spacing="3.5" fill="#43331f">THE GALÁPAGOS TORTOISE</text> <text x="320" y="447" text-anchor="middle" font-family="'Liberation Sans','DejaVu Sans',sans-serif" font-size="8.5" letter-spacing="2.5" fill="#6f5a40">CHELONOIDIS NIGER</text> </svg>

<figcaption><em>Plate 2. The Galápagos giant tortoise, Chelonoidis niger complex — a perfect ship's larder in the age of sail, and among the first casualties of the curious appetite this volume will reckon with in Chapter 6.</em></figcaption> </figure>

<figure> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="100%" viewBox="0 0 640 500" role="img"><title>THE BEAGLE'S LARDER — specimens of the naturalist's opportunistic table</title>  <rect x="11" y="11" width="618" height="478" fill="none" stroke="#43331f" stroke-width="1.3"/> <rect x="18" y="18" width="604" height="464" fill="none" stroke="#43331f" stroke-width="0.6"/> <path d="M28 28h18M28 28v18M612 28h-18M612 28v18M28 472h18M28 472v-18M612 472h-18M612 472v-18" fill="none" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="1.3"/>  <text x="320" y="44" text-anchor="middle" font-family="'Liberation Sans','DejaVu Sans',sans-serif" font-size="9" letter-spacing="3" fill="#6f5a40">H · M · S · BEAGLE 1831 – 1836</text> <path d="M234 52H406" fill="none" stroke="#a9906c" stroke-width="0.7"/>  <g fill="none" font-family="'Liberation Sans','DejaVu Sans',sans-serif" font-size="8" text-anchor="middle"> <circle cx="128" cy="74" r="9" stroke="#b5502a" stroke-width="0.9"/><text x="128" y="77" fill="#b5502a">I</text> <circle cx="320" cy="74" r="9" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/><text x="320" y="77" fill="#6f5a40">II</text> <circle cx="512" cy="74" r="9" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/><text x="512" y="77" fill="#6f5a40">III</text> <circle cx="128" cy="262" r="9" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/><text x="128" y="265" fill="#6f5a40">IV</text> <circle cx="320" cy="262" r="9" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/><text x="320" y="265" fill="#6f5a40">V</text> <circle cx="512" cy="262" r="9" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/><text x="512" y="265" fill="#6f5a40">VI</text> </g>  <g fill="none" stroke="#43331f" stroke-width="1.2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round">  <path d="M98 152C96 132 116 122 132 124C152 126 160 140 158 156C156 174 128 182 110 176C100 172 98 162 98 152Z"/> <path d="M150 132C158 114 164 102 170 92M156 134C164 116 169 104 174 94"/> <path d="M166 92C164 86 172 82 177 86C181 90 178 96 172 96C168 96 166 95 166 92Z"/> <path d="M179 89L190 91L179 93"/> <path d="M148 138C136 150 118 154 106 150"/> <path d="M100 150C88 146 79 150 74 158M102 158C90 158 82 164 80 172M106 166C96 168 90 174 90 182" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.9"/> <path d="M120 176C122 184 117 189 119 194M119 194l-5 5M119 194l1 6M119 194l6 5M138 174C140 184 134 189 136 195M136 195l-5 5M136 195l1 6M136 195l6 5"/> <path d="M110 146l14 3M108 154l16 3M110 162l14 3M116 138l12 3" stroke="#a9906c" stroke-width="0.7"/>  <path d="M282 164C278 118 350 118 346 164"/> <path d="M282 164q9 8 18 0q9 8 18 0q9 8 18 0q6 6 10 0"/> <path d="M300 124C314 118 334 118 344 132M292 142C314 134 332 134 346 144" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/> <path d="M304 122L308 160M324 119L324 162M342 126L344 160" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.8"/> <path d="M344 162C364 152 382 143 394 130M340 156C360 146 378 138 390 126"/> <path d="M388 124C386 117 398 114 403 120C406 126 400 131 393 129C389 128 388 126 388 124Z"/> <path d="M403 123L409 124"/> <path d="M300 164C296 176 296 184 300 188L314 188C316 182 314 174 310 164M300 188l-3 5M307 188l0 6M314 188l3 5"/> <path d="M330 166C328 178 330 185 334 188L346 188C348 182 346 174 344 166M334 188l-2 5M340 188l0 6M346 188l2 5"/> <path d="M296 138C312 132 326 132 340 138" stroke="#a9906c" stroke-width="0.7"/>  <path d="M462 142C480 130 540 130 560 142"/> <path d="M560 142C570 138 579 143 581 149C579 155 570 155 563 151"/> <path d="M581 149L587 151L581 154M562 135L565 127L570 135M570 134L574 127L578 135"/> <path d="M560 151C561 167 559 180 559 190M553 190L565 190"/> <path d="M474 152C500 163 536 163 559 152"/> <path d="M468 144C457 156 457 177 466 179C470 180 474 177 474 172M470 179L470 190M464 190L476 190"/> <path d="M540 158L540 190M534 190L546 190M488 160L488 190M482 190L494 190"/> <path d="M462 144C447 148 439 166 445 184C449 194 458 194 460 186"/> <path d="M476 140l10 4M490 135l10 4M540 137l8 4M468 150l8 3" stroke="#a9906c" stroke-width="0.7"/>  <path d="M94 328C98 300 150 300 158 324"/> <path d="M158 324C170 320 180 322 186 328C180 332 172 332 166 330"/> <path d="M186 328L190 330L186 332M162 310C160 304 167 302 170 307C170 311 165 313 162 310"/> <path d="M94 328C97 346 108 353 118 353M132 353C146 351 155 340 158 326"/> <path d="M138 351L140 372M140 372l-3 3M140 372l4 3M110 351C106 360 108 368 112 370L114 372M114 372l-3 3M114 372l4 3M150 349L152 372"/> <path d="M94 328C88 326 84 328 82 332"/> <path d="M106 316l12 3M110 322l14 3M120 310l12 3" stroke="#a9906c" stroke-width="0.7"/>  <path d="M292 344C288 312 348 312 356 340"/> <path d="M292 344C300 350 348 349 356 340"/> <path d="M356 340C366 334 379 335 389 341C381 345 372 345 364 343M389 341L394 342L389 345M360 331C358 326 365 325 367 329"/> <path d="M306 314C304 328 304 338 306 349M318 312C316 326 316 338 318 349M330 312C328 326 328 338 330 349M342 314C340 327 340 337 342 348" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.9"/> <path d="M292 342C276 346 260 352 248 360M280 345l-2 4M270 348l-2 4M260 352l-2 4"/> <path d="M306 349L306 356M320 350L320 357M336 349L336 356M306 356l-2 3M306 356l3 3M320 357l-2 3M320 357l3 3M336 356l-2 3M336 356l3 3"/> <path d="M298 330l3 0M300 336l3 0M348 330l3 0M350 336l3 0" stroke="#a9906c" stroke-width="0.9"/>  <path d="M470 332C482 322 544 322 560 330"/> <path d="M470 332C484 342 544 342 560 330"/> <path d="M560 330C572 326 584 330 588 336C584 342 572 344 560 336M588 337L581 338M566 337C566 341 570 343 574 341"/> <path d="M486 324l-2 -7M498 322l-1 -8M510 321l0 -8M522 321l1 -8M534 322l2 -7M546 324l2 -7" stroke="#6f5a40" stroke-width="0.9"/> <path d="M470 334C450 338 428 346 408 358M456 337l-2 5M442 341l-2 5M428 346l-2 5M416 351l-2 5"/> <path d="M544 340C546 348 546 354 544 358M544 358l-4 3M544 358l0 4M544 358l4 3M486 340C484 348 484 354 486 358M486 358l-4 3M486 358l0 4M486 358l4 3"/> <path d="M494 330l10 3M510 330l10 3M526 330l10 3" stroke="#a9906c" stroke-width="0.7"/> </g>  <g fill="#43331f" stroke="none"> <circle cx="171" cy="88" r="1.3"/><circle cx="395" cy="121" r="1.3"/><circle cx="572" cy="144" r="1.2"/><circle cx="585" cy="151" r="1"/> <circle cx="165" cy="318" r="1.2"/><circle cx="363" cy="336" r="1.1"/><circle cx="577" cy="332" r="1.3"/> </g>  <g font-family="'Liberation Sans','DejaVu Sans',sans-serif" font-size="11" letter-spacing="2" fill="#43331f" text-anchor="middle"> <text x="128" y="216">LESSER RHEA</text> <text x="320" y="216">GALÁPAGOS TORTOISE</text> <text x="512" y="216">PUMA</text> <text x="128" y="396">AGOUTI</text> <text x="320" y="396">ARMADILLO</text> <text x="512" y="396">IGUANA</text> </g> <path d="M40 236H600" fill="none" stroke="#c8b79a" stroke-width="0.7" stroke-dasharray="1 5"/> <text x="320" y="426" text-anchor="middle" font-family="'Liberation Sans','DejaVu Sans',sans-serif" font-size="8" letter-spacing="0.5" fill="#6f5a40">I. eaten aboard before it was recognised as a species new to science</text>  <text x="320" y="458" text-anchor="middle" font-family="'Liberation Sans','DejaVu Sans',sans-serif" font-size="13" letter-spacing="3.5" fill="#43331f">THE BEAGLE'S LARDER</text> <text x="320" y="474" text-anchor="middle" font-family="'Liberation Sans','DejaVu Sans',sans-serif" font-size="8.5" letter-spacing="2.5" fill="#6f5a40">SPECIMENS OF THE NATURALIST'S TABLE</text> </svg>

<figcaption><em>Plate 3. The Beagle's larder — a specimen-array of the creatures Darwin ate and appraised on the voyage: lesser rhea, giant tortoise, the twenty-pound cavy, armadillo, puma and land iguana, the opportunistic table of a working naturalist.</em></figcaption> </figure>

The Naturalist's Dilemma

Run the chapter's episodes together and a genuine methodological problem emerges from behind the comedy: again and again, the thing Darwin most wanted to study was the thing his companions were about to eat. The lesser rhea was three-quarters consumed before he recognised it, and survived to science only because a few bones and feathers were snatched back from the dinner things. The Galápagos tortoises he carried home were young ones, too immature to show the island-by-island differences that mattered most, while the tell-tale adult shells — the ones that might have proved the case — went over the side of the Beagle unlabelled, their island of origin lost with them. Even the Fuegian fungus reached Berkeley's description only because Darwin thought, between mouthfuls, to keep some.

To eat the evidence is the naturalist-gourmand's occupational hazard, and it cuts to the heart of what this whole tradition was and was not. At its best, tasting a creature was a real act of knowledge — one more sense trained on a specimen already measured and drawn. At its careless worst, it destroyed the very object it sought to understand, and it did so most easily with exactly the creatures least able to spare the loss: the rare, the slow, the island-bound. The rhea was saved by luck and the tortoises half-lost by haste, and the difference between the two outcomes is, in miniature, the difference this volume keeps returning to — between a curiosity that leaves the world intact and one that eats its way through it. Darwin, characteristically, recorded both without flinching, and left his readers to draw the line he had not always managed to draw himself.

Curiosity as a Way of Knowing

What unites the Cambridge owl and the Patagonian rhea and the Galápagos tortoise is a cast of mind that the modern reader has to work a little to recover. For Darwin and his generation, tasting a creature was not a transgression against science but a branch of it — a final, intimate act of attention paid to a specimen already measured, sketched, and skinned. The Glutton Club was juvenile and the ship's table was practical, but both expressed the same underlying idea: that the world is to be known by every available sense, and that the palate, disciplined and curious, has its own contribution to make to natural history. That the same voyage which fed him also furnished the two rheas and the island tortoises — the very facts that would unpick the fixity of species — is the chapter's deepest irony. The appetite and the theory drew, more than once, on the same animal.

There is a last, human irony that belongs at the close. The young man who ate his way across a continent — puma and cavy, iguana and tortoise, and one live beetle by mistake — spent almost the whole of his later life a chronic invalid, his rebellious stomach reduced to the plainest of diets, dosing and dieting and retreating from rich dinners and long evenings alike. The great eater became the great dyspeptic. Whatever lay behind that decades-long ill-health, and it has been argued over from his own day to ours, the man who wrote the freshest tasting-notes in the history of natural history passed his last thirty years largely unable to enjoy a meal.

That idea, pushed a little further and dressed in Victorian earnestness, was about to become something close to a movement. Darwin was the most celebrated of the naturalist-gourmands, but he was very far from the only one, and in the decades after the Beagle returned, a whole society of scientists, sportsmen and eccentrics would take up the proposition that the animal kingdom was not merely to be classified but to be tasted, catalogued by flavour, and — in their grander ambitions — served at the imperial table itself. It is to those explorer-gourmands, and to the strange and revealing project they called acclimatisation, that the next chapter turns.

Darwin ate his specimens almost by the way, a naturalist's habit worn lightly, and hardly noticed that two of his dinners had quietly begun to dismantle the fixed order of creation. The men of the next chapter would make the same habit into a cause, complete with dining societies, printed menus, and the earnest conviction that England's tables were waiting to be stocked with the wildlife of the world.

บทถัดไป · 5 / 15Chapter 2 — The Explorer-Gourmands